Gall's Law

Have you ever tried to build something complex, like a LEGO set, without following the step-by-step instructions? 

It usually ends up being frustrating and might not even work properly. But when you follow the instructions, starting with a simple foundation and gradually adding pieces, you can build amazing things. 

This is the essence of Gall’s Law – the idea that complex systems that work always evolve from simpler systems that worked first.

Think of it like learning to ride a bike. You don’t start with a complex racing bicycle and try to master it immediately. Instead, you might begin with training wheels, then progress to a basic two-wheeler, and eventually work your way up to more advanced bikes as your skills improve.

What is Gall's Law?

Gall’s Law states that all complex systems that work evolved from simpler systems that worked. It’s a fundamental principle that teaches us that successful complex systems don’t emerge fully formed – they develop gradually through a process of refinement and adaptation.

There are two key aspects to understanding Gall’s Law:

1. Evolution over Design

Complex systems should grow and evolve rather than being designed from scratch.

2. Working Foundation

Each stage of the system must work effectively before adding more complexity.

Simple System Growing System Complex System Evolution over Design Grow and evolve naturally Working Foundation Each stage must work effectively

Why Complex Systems Fail When Designed From Scratch

When people try to create complex systems all at once, they often run into problems:

  • Unforeseen Variables: There are too many interconnected parts and potential issues to predict everything in advance.
  • Lack of Testing: The system hasn’t been exposed to real-world challenges that help identify and fix problems.
  • Overwhelming Complexity: Without a simple foundation to build upon, it’s hard to understand and manage all the moving parts.

Gall's Law in Real Life

We can see Gall’s Law at work in many successful systems around us:

Social Media Platforms

Facebook started as a simple college directory before evolving into the complex social network we know today.

Transportation Systems

Modern airports evolved from simple airfields, gradually adding terminals, security systems, and commercial areas.

Natural Evolution

Living organisms evolved from simple single-celled life forms to complex creatures through millions of years of gradual change.

Language Development

 Complex languages evolved from simple systems of communication, gradually adding vocabulary and grammar rules.

Why is Gall's Law Important?

Understanding Gall’s Law helps us approach complex challenges more effectively:

Reduces Risk: Starting simple and evolving gradually reduces the risk of catastrophic failure.

Enables Learning: Each stage of development provides valuable insights and lessons.

Promotes Adaptability: Systems that evolve gradually are better able to adapt to changing conditions.

Ensures Functionality: By building on working components, you maintain functionality throughout development.

Hands-On Learning

Here are some activities to help understand and apply Gall’s Law:

  1. Build Something Complex
    • Start with a simple version of what you want to create
    • Test it to make sure it works
    • Gradually add features and complexity
    • Notice how each addition builds on what came before
  2. Analyze Successful Systems
    • Choose a complex system you use regularly (like a smartphone app)
    • Research its early versions
    • Track how it evolved over time
    • Identify the simple foundation it started from
  3. Practice Incremental Development
    • Pick a skill you want to learn
    • Break it down into simple, manageable steps
    • Master each step before moving to the next
    • Observe how complex abilities emerge from simple foundations

Remember, Gall’s Law teaches us that the path to complexity is through simplicity. When building any system, start small, ensure it works, and then gradually add complexity. 

This approach might take more time initially, but it’s more likely to result in a successful, robust system in the long run.

Movie Recommendation: Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs (2009)

Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs offers a delightfully chaotic demonstration of Gall’s Law through Flint Lockwood’s journey from simple food replicator to world-threatening weather machine.

Through Flint’s initial success with basic food production and subsequent spiral into uncontrollable complexity, students witness how complex systems must evolve from simple, working foundations rather than being built from scratch.

The film cleverly illustrates this principle as Flint’s FLDSMDFR moves from producing basic spaghetti to generating food storms and giant meatballs, showing how rushing to add complexity without mastering simplicity leads to system failure.

As viewers follow Flint’s realization that he must shut down his creation and start over with a simpler version, they learn how Gall’s Law applies to any complex system – from food-making machines to real-world technologies.

Through its imaginative premise, the film demonstrates why working simple systems provide the only reliable foundation for building sustainable complexity.

Song: Simple First

Verse 1:
Like a LEGO masterpiece
Built from blocks with gentle ease
Complex dreams need time to grow
Starting simple, taking slow
Pre-Chorus:
Evolution’s quiet art
Working pieces from the start
Layer by layer, test and learn
Watch the simple pages turn
Chorus:
Simple First, that’s how we grow
Nature always seems to know
Build foundations, make them strong
Simple First, then move along
Verse 2:
Social networks start as seeds
Languages grow word by word
Flying fields become the scenes
Where airports rise, once they’ve learned
(Pre-Chorus)
(Chorus)
Bridge:

In the space between the start
And the dreams within our hearts
Lies a path of patient grace
As complexity finds its place
(Chorus)