Home / Mental Models

Sturgeon's Law: Navigating the Sea of Mediocrity

In a world saturated with information, options, and opinions, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by the sheer volume of what’s available. 

How do we separate the wheat from the chaff, the gems from the junk? 

Enter Sturgeon’s Law, a powerful mental model that reminds us that “90% of everything is crap.” 

Understanding and applying this concept is crucial for navigating the sea of mediocrity and focusing our time and energy on what truly matters.

In this article, we’ll dive into the essence of Sturgeon’s Law, its practical applications for clear thinking and decision-making, and strategies for harnessing its wisdom for personal growth and success. We’ll also explore methods for introducing this valuable concept to children, equipping them with the tools to become discerning consumers of information and experiences

The Origin and Significance of Sturgeon's Law

Sturgeon’s Law, succinctly stated as “90% of everything is crap,” was coined by science fiction author Theodore Sturgeon in response to criticism of his genre. He argued that if you judged any field, from literature to consumer goods, by its worst examples, you’d inevitably conclude that 90% of it was subpar. The remaining 10%, however, was where the true value lay.

This mental model serves as a call for discernment and selectivity. It encourages us to avoid fixating on the overwhelming majority of mediocre offerings and instead direct our time and energy towards the 10% that holds genuine worth. By embracing Sturgeon’s Law, we prioritize quality over quantity and develop a more critical, discerning approach to the world around us.

Sturgeon's Law: 90% vs. 10% 90% "Crap" 10% "Quality" Literature 90%: Forgettable 10%: Classics Consumer Goods 90%: Mediocre 10%: Excellence "Focus your energy on finding the valuable 10%" - Theodore Sturgeon

Practical Applications for Clear Thinking

Sturgeon’s Law has twofold implications for clear thinking. First, it reminds us that much of the information we encounter is likely to be irrelevant, inaccurate, or simply not worth our attention. In an age of information overload, where we’re bombarded with a constant stream of data, opinions, and content, this realization is more important than ever.

Second, Sturgeon’s Law encourages us to shift our focus away from the ‘crap’ and concentrate on the elements that are truly meaningful and insightful. By developing our critical thinking skills and becoming more discerning consumers of information, we can navigate the sea of mediocrity and prioritize sources and content that offer genuine value.

This mental model is particularly relevant in fields like media consumption, where the vast majority of content may be superficial or misleading. By applying Sturgeon’s Law, we can learn to identify and seek out the 10% of media that informs, enlightens, and enriches our understanding of the world.

Information Filtering with Sturgeon's Law Information Stream Critical Thinking Filter • Relevance • Accuracy • Value Quality Information The Valuable 10% • Meaningful insights • Reliable data • Enriched understanding

Teaching Sturgeon's Law to Children

Helping children understand and apply the principles of Sturgeon’s Law is an invaluable gift that can equip them with the tools to navigate an increasingly complex and information-saturated world.

Here are some strategies for introducing this concept to young minds:

1. Use Relatable Examples
Start with examples children can easily grasp, such as toys or candy. Explain that in a big box of toys, most might be broken or less enjoyable (the ‘crap’), but a few are special and exciting (the valuable 10%). This concrete illustration helps children understand the core idea behind Sturgeon’s Law.

2. Encourage Critical Thinking
Use Sturgeon’s Law as a springboard for discussions about quality and value. Ask children to think about their favorite books, movies, or games and what makes them stand out from the rest. By encouraging them to articulate why certain things are special, you help them develop their own critical thinking skills.

3. Emphasize the Positive
While Sturgeon’s Law highlights the prevalence of mediocrity, it’s important to focus on the positive aspects of seeking out quality. Frame the law as a tool for finding the best and most enjoyable things in life, rather than dwelling on the negative.

4. Model Discernment
Children often learn by example, so it’s crucial to model the principles of Sturgeon’s Law in your own life. Share your own processes for evaluating information, making decisions, and prioritizing quality. By demonstrating these skills in action, you help children internalize their importance.

Applying Sturgeon's Law for Personal Growth

Beyond its applications in clear thinking and decision-making, Sturgeon’s Law can also be a powerful tool for personal development.

Here are some ways to leverage this mental model for your own growth:

  • Information Diet

    Use Sturgeon’s Law to curate your information diet.

      • Instead of consuming a large volume of low-quality content, focus on seeking out the 10% of sources that offer genuine insight, accuracy, and depth.
      • By prioritizing quality over quantity, you can make more informed decisions and avoid the pitfalls of misinformation.

  • Productivity and Time Management

    Apply Sturgeon’s Law to your tasks and activities.

      • Identify the 20% of efforts that produce 80% of your results (the Pareto Principle) and prioritize those high-impact actions.

      • By focusing on the most valuable tasks and minimizing time spent on less consequential ones, you can optimize your productivity and achieve your goals more efficiently.

  • Experiences and Relationships

    Use Sturgeon’s Law as a guide for selecting experiences and cultivating relationships.

      • Recognize that most experiences will be average, but by actively seeking out the exceptional ones, you can enrich your life and create lasting memories.

      • Similarly, focus on nurturing the relationships that bring the most joy, growth, and fulfillment, rather than spreading yourself thin across a multitude of superficial connections.

  • Continuous Improvement

    Embrace Sturgeon’s Law as a catalyst for continuous improvement.

      • By constantly seeking out the best and most valuable elements in any given field or endeavor, you push yourself to raise your own standards and strive for excellence.

      • Use this mental model as a reminder to never settle for mediocrity and to always be on the lookout for opportunities to learn, grow, and optimize.

Conclusion

Sturgeon’s Law reminds us that in a world filled with mediocrity, we must actively seek out what truly matters. By developing a discerning approach, we can navigate past the 90% of ‘crap’ to find the valuable 10%.

Teaching this concept and applying it in our lives helps build better judgment and prioritization skills.

Remember, like a prospector panning for gold, the ability to separate the valuable from the worthless is what turns the overwhelming into the extraordinary.

Recommended Activities for Students

Objective: To identify and appreciate quality amidst a sea of mediocrity.

  1. Fill a large container with various items, such as toys, books, or snacks. Ensure that about 10% of the items are of noticeably higher quality or value.
  2. Divide the children into small groups and explain the concept of Sturgeon’s Law using the container as an example.
  3. Challenge each group to work together to find the “treasures” (the high-quality items) among the rest.
  4. After the treasure hunt, have each group present their findings and discuss what makes these items stand out from the others.
  5. Facilitate a discussion on how Sturgeon’s Law applies to other areas of life and the importance of seeking out quality.

Objective: To apply Sturgeon’s Law in a real-world context.

  1. Present a real-world scenario where Sturgeon’s Law might apply (e.g., selecting a new book for the school library, choosing a charity to support, or deciding on a class project).
  2. Divide the children into small groups and have each group brainstorm a list of potential options for the given scenario.
  3. Ask each group to evaluate their options using the principles of Sturgeon’s Law, identifying the top 10% that offer the most value or potential impact.
  4. Have each group present their top choices and the reasoning behind their selections.
  5. As a class, discuss the process of applying Sturgeon’s Law to real-world decisions and the benefits of prioritizing quality over quantity.

Objective: To practice critical thinking and discernment in media consumption.

  1. Have each child choose a book, movie, or TV show they have recently enjoyed.
  2. Ask them to write a short review, analyzing what makes the chosen media stand out from others in its category.
  3. Encourage the children to consider aspects such as storytelling, characters, originality, and overall impact.
  4. Have each child present their review to the group, explaining why they believe their chosen media represents the valuable 10%.
  5. Facilitate a discussion on the importance of critical thinking in media consumption and how to identify quality content.

Objective: To research and identify examples of excellence in a chosen field.

  1. Have each child or pair choose a field or topic of interest (e.g., sports, music, science, or art).
  2. Challenge them to research and identify three to five examples of individuals, works, or achievements that represent the top 10% in their chosen field.
  3. Ask the children to create a presentation or report showcasing their findings, explaining what sets these examples apart from the rest.
  4. Have each child or pair share their Quality Quest with the class, discussing the characteristics and impact of the examples they identified.
  5. Facilitate a discussion on the importance of seeking out and learning from the best in any given field.

Objective: To critically analyze the application and limitations of Sturgeon’s Law.

  1. Divide the class into two teams: one in favor of Sturgeon’s Law and one challenging its universal applicability.
  2. Give each team time to research and prepare arguments supporting their position. The team in favor should focus on examples and benefits of applying Sturgeon’s Law, while the challenging team should explore potential limitations or exceptions.
  3. Conduct a structured debate, with each team presenting their arguments and responding to counterarguments from the opposing team.
  4. After the debate, facilitate a discussion on the strengths and limitations of Sturgeon’s Law, emphasizing the importance of critical thinking and context when applying mental models.
  5. Encourage the children to reflect on how they can use the principles of Sturgeon’s Law in their own lives while remaining open to nuance and exceptions.

Song: 10% That Shine

(Verse 1)
In a world full of noise and distraction
Where mediocrity vies for our attention
Sturgeon’s Law reminds us, clear and true
90% of everything, just won’t do

(Chorus)
But we’ll seek out the 10% that shine
The gems that make our hearts entwine
With discerning eyes and critical minds
We’ll leave the sea of crap behind

(Verse 2)
Information overload, a constant stream
Opinions and content, an endless scheme
But we’ll shift our focus, to what’s truly grand
The 10% that helps us understand

(Bridge)
Teach the children, to navigate this maze
To find the quality, in the haze
Encourage critical thinking, and a positive view
To seek out the best, in all they do

(Chorus)
‘Cause we’ll seek out the 10% that shine
The gems that make our hearts entwine
With discerning eyes and critical minds
We’ll leave the sea of crap behind

(Verse 3)
In our personal growth, and the choices we make
Sturgeon’s Law, a tool to take
Curate our info diet, optimize our time
Cultivate relationships, that are sublime

(Outro)
So let’s embrace, this mental model’s might
To navigate mediocrity, with all our might
In a world of crap, we’ll make our stand
For the 10% that shines, across the land

Question More, Action Knowledge.

Remember, at QMAK, we don’t just teach; we empower. We don’t just inform; we inspire. We don’t just question; we act. Become a Gold Member, and let’s unlock your child’s full potential, one question at a time.

Facebook Twitter Google-plus Pinterest
Copyright 2025 © All rights Reserved. Question More, Action Knowledge. QMAK.com